To liven up the rather boring ordinary Markley’s Law Monday QOTD, I offer this:
Jazz fans and gun owners are apparently among the most sexually active Americans. #SexTrivia
Swingles @swingles
Posted on X, August 14, 2023
I have no idea what the basis for this is. And I’ve asked two different chat bots who also come up empty. Here is what Grok has to say:
Joe: Someone on X claims, “Jazz fans and gun owners are apparently among the most sexually active Americans.” Is there any truth to this?
Grok: Thereβs no direct, credible evidence from recent studies or data that specifically links jazz fans and gun owners to being “among the most sexually active Americans.” The claim seems to stem from a mix of speculation, anecdotal chatter, or possibly a misreading of unrelated research, but it doesnβt hold up under scrutiny based on available information.
Letβs break it down:
- Jazz Fans: No studies in the provided context or broader research landscape tie jazz fandom to sexual activity rates. Music preference might influence mood or social behaviorβplenty of people associate jazz with romance or seductionβbut thereβs no data showing jazz fans as a group are notably more sexually active than others. Itβs a stretch without evidence.
- Gun Owners: Thereβs been some research on gun ownership and sexual behavior, but it debunks rather than supports the claim. A 2021 study in the American Journal of Menβs Health analyzed data from 780 men and found no association between sexual dysfunction and gun ownership. This counters older psychoanalytic theories (e.g., guns as phallic symbols tied to virility), but it doesnβt suggest gun owners are more sexually active eitherβjust that thereβs no link to dysfunction. Sexual activity frequency wasnβt directly measured in this context, and no other recent, representative surveys connect gun ownership to higher sexual activity.
- Overlap or Generalization: The X claim might be riffing off stereotypesβjazz fans as passionate, gun owners as assertiveβbut stereotypes arenβt data. The 2015 Harvard/Northeastern survey on gun ownership (55 million U.S. owners, 3% owning half the guns) and Pewβs 2017 gun owner demographics (30% of adults) give us numbers but say nothing about sexual habits. Similarly, no national surveys like the General Social Survey tie music tastes and gun ownership to sex.
Without a specific, peer-reviewed study backing this exact claimβand none appears in recent literature or the search contextβitβs likely just a provocative quip from X, not a fact. People throw out wild assertions online all the time, and this one smells like itβs more about attention than accuracy. If someoneβs got a study from 2024 or early 2025 I havenβt seen, Iβd be happy to reconsider, but as of now, itβs baseless.
What do you thinkβdid the X poster cite anything, or was it just a hot take?
Joe: I suspect it was just someone trying to get attention by saying something controversial.
Grok: Yeah, that tracks. X is a breeding ground for attention-grabbers tossing out wild claims with no substance. βJazz fans and gun owners are the horniest Americansβ has that perfect mix of quirky and edgy to bait reactionsβdoesnβt need to be true, just loud. Probably worked, too, since weβre talking about it. Classic move. Anything else from X catching your eye lately?
Like this:
Like Loading...