I’m Not Making this Up!

Quote of the Day

The Supreme Court will soon hear arguments in December in Viramontes v. Cook County, a challenge to state and local bans on AR-15 semiautomatic rifles. The challengers say the rifles are “in common use” for lawful purposes such as self-defense. The state governments defending their gun-bans say they are weapons better suited to war than to civilian life.

Neither side recognizes that the Second Amendment’s reference to the “militia” counts in favor of protecting AR-15s either way.

The challengers emphasize self-defense, an individually focused concern, while the governments argue that AR-15s’ military character is a reason to ban them. But AR-15s are the sort of small arms historically suited for a militia. This is actually the heart of the case, as we argued in a friend-of-the-court brief for the Cato Institute.

Small arms that an infantryman would historically have kept and borne are not marginal to the Second Amendment. Rather, they sit at its center.

Matthew P. Cavedon
October 27, 2026
Opinion: The ‘weapon of war’ argument has backfired on AR-15 bans

I thought the “weapon of war” argument would be dropped by the anti-gun lawyers. They should know that the Miller decision said only guns useful for the militia were protected. The argument had some weight when used by and for ignorant anti-gun people.

Either the anti-gun lawyers are willfully ignorant, or they are so stupid as to believe the pro rights lawyers and SCOTUS are ignorant because they are trying to make that argument fly. The other argument they are trying to make is that AR-15s are not “arms” and therefore are not protected by the Second Amendment.

I’m not making this up! They really are trying to sell those arguments:

There is another thing they are arguing that is a deliberate lie. And it’s almost clever. They are saying “unusually dangerous” weapons can be constitutionally banned. They are conflating the “dangerous and unusual” phrase from Heller. They will not get away with that.

We are going to win this case in a big way. Mark Smith thinks is possible we may even get a 9-0 decision:

I’m skeptical of that, but looking at the quality of the arguments I’m nearly certain it will be an easy win.

6 thoughts on “I’m Not Making this Up!”

  1. I think they are counting on John Roberts being a snake and bringing his mini-me along. They may be right and I hope that Alito and Thomas are good at vote counting.

    • Counting on dishonesty from Roberts is often a good bet. More that many other judges, he wouldn’t know a Constitutional principle if it conked him on the head.

  2. The clown who tried to show how ARs put out 60,000 foot-pounds of energy per minute cracks me up. He is trying to invent a measure of lethality called “Muzzle Energy per Minute” or “MEpM.” My answer to that foolishness is to compare it to another privately owned Revolutionary War weapon, The private warship Caesar of Boston.

    Revolutionary War private warship Caesar of Boston had 26 guns. Worst case they were 9 pounders firing every 2 minutes @ 1,400 fps for 274K ft-lbs/shot

    13 guns (one side) every 2 minutes is 1,781,000 ft-lbs/min, roughly 30 times his calculated “MEpM” for an AR15.

    Checkmate!

    https://x.com/SorrentinoSean/status/2115822456392786136?a=P6Kx6t4HLk_kEoNyasc&s=20

  3. The leftists are intent on taking over the nation (planet, really), through violence if lawfare proves too challenging, and they KNOW the 2nd Amendment is a huge road block for their plans. That is why they constantly attack the gun-rights of civilians (while advocating looser restrictions and blanket amnesty for their orcs in uniform). The perversion of language to reach their goal of banning anything that threatens their hold on power is nothing, NOTHING for them to perform. They know what they plan to do will get them shot. It’s that simple.

  4. Under Mexico’s reasoning in Smith & Wesson v. Mexico, every government on Earth can ban Toyota pickups because revolutionaries, rebels, and militias the world over weld on frames for belt-fed machine guns and turn them into “technicals,” and Toyota is clearly at fault for designing and marketing those pickups for that purpose.

    And nevermind that Toyota has never advertised their trucks’ suitability as “technicals,” or that the vast majority of Toyota pickups in the world do NOT have belt-fed weapons welded on, and were purchased because Toyota’s design is solid and proven as a vehicle useful for both work and leisure.

    Under SCOTUS’ (correct) reasoning, those design features make them attractive for normal people all over the world, and Toyota cannot be blamed simply because rebel militias like them, too.

    That said, I’m still not as hopeful as Mark Smith that Viramontes v. Cook County will be a 9-0 unanimous decision. I suspect it will be a 6-3, but not necessarily along expected party lines. I don’t discount Notorious KBJ’s ability to nonsense herself to the end result she wants and wouldn’t necessarily put it past Sotomayor to join it. Kagan may uphold stare decisis, but I still don’t trust ACB or Roberts on straight-up 2A issues. (As Mark Smith notes, S&W v. Mexico was 9-0, but was presented as a PLCAA case, not a 2A one. Also, the “design and marketing” angles have 1A implications — whether that was directly argued or not — and not even the liberal justices want to rule against the First Amendment.)

    I hope I’m wrong and Mr. Smith has a better read than I do.

  5. You’re missing the big picture. The Democrats are planning on frauding themselves into power and expanding the Supreme Court to give themselves a majority, which will at the very least overturn Heller, MacDonald, and Bruen, and more likely will rule private gun ownership illegal.

    If by some miracle they fail in 2026, they will just do it in another election.

    Republicans need to grow a pair of balls and realize that as long as there are a large number of Democrats that we are never more than two years away from literally endless Communism. Therefore we need to reduce their numbers until they are about the same as the Natural Law Party.

    Yes, I mean that exactly the way it sounds.

Comments are closed.