Alan Korwin is in line

Tomorrow is a very big day in history for gun rights activists and even in the legal history of this country. I expect the only bigger legal day in my lifetime will be when the decision is announced in a few months. For some reason it never occurred to me to attend the oral arguments; to be a part of history in the making. To be able to say, “I was there and I heard it with my own ears and saw the sweat dripping from the lawyers who were fighting to win what will probably be the most important case of their lives.”

Others are there and will be a part of the history being made tomorrow. And they deserve those places much more than I do so it’s appropriate that I’m at the opposite side of the continent working on Plan B¬†should it ever be needed.

One of the people who earned a seat at tomorrows event sent me an email:

Full contact info at end

DATELINE: Washington, D.C. 3/17/08

24 Hours Prior to Heller Case

by Alan Korwin, Co-Author
Supreme Court Gun Cases

More people are on line in front of the U.S. Supreme Court for the D.C.
gun ban case tomorrow than seats are available, and the temperature is hovering above freezing, but that’s not stopping them.

Bob Blackmer and I were the first to arrive, Sunday night about 5 p.m., answering the big question of — Would two nights in advance be enough
— aside from did we have endurance to pull that off.

A few moments later, Jason and Dan arrived from Pennsylvania with sleeping bags and the same question in mind — would they be in time for the biggest Second Amendment case in the nation’s history, and, yes, they were. With no one else around, and the Sup. Ct. police officer pumped for all the info he might have (precious little), Bob and I left for our hotel, confident that we would be in time in the a.m., and Jason and Dan became numbers one and two in line, a distinction the media would dwell on the next day. (Reporters kept zeroing in on Jason since he was number one in line, and fortunately, he was articulate, a poli sci grad, not the bubba the media so often isolates as a “typical”

Because the line formed two nights in advance (kind of), and because local ABC-TV carried that news (with images)and bloggers spread it, people began arriving first at midnight, and then at the crack of dawn, panicked about access. Bob awoke in the hotel and departed in time to arrive well before 8 a.m., making him 7th, and I ran around looking for propane for his porta-heater (the airline allowed the heater but not the fuel). I was fortunate to have a reserved seat, so it didn’t matter that I arrived at 10 a.m., and that didn’t matter either, since I was now #16. I was the only person, the whole day, schmoozing on the line, running errands for people, enjoying the atmosphere, but with a reserved seat and a bed waiting for me at night.

People had full blown lounge chairs, sleeping bags, blankets, food… a regular shanty town developed and as police had advised, the line self regulated. Physical position was a non-issue, since everyone knew their place, and Sarah, a Harvard law student, took it on herself to start a list and gather everyone’s arrival time and position number. People milled around at will, confident they would not lose their cherished place in line. It was a community.

Almost everyone was a law student, almost no one would qualify as a “gunnie” (well, maybe a small handful) but nearly everyone was on the side of Heller, advocating for a strong Second Amendment. The conversations were electric, a bunch of well educated, thoughtful, intelligent people self selected for a historic moment. When was the last time you saw a line of people hanging out reading legal briefs?

The promise was for 50 seats for the public, but the Marsahll’s office was clear to me that this number could change, and would only be known in the morning, giving a distinct feeling it would shrink as “dignitaries” decided to attend at the last minute.

By 2:30 p.m. Monday, today, the day before the case, 32 people were in line, neatly numbered thanks to Sarah (and everyone in line ahead of them). The lucky (maybe) 50th person arrived at 4:45 p.m., and folks continued to arrive and queue up, hoping against hope for a greater number of seats, or line abandoners.

No paid place holders were apparent.

The most novel legal theories were:

— The case could be decided on standing, with the Court concluding Heller didn’t really have any after all, and the case falling apart on those grounds (highly unlikely, but it shook up conversations);

— The Court would parse “keep” and “bear,” finding an individual right, but applying strict scurtiny to “keep” and rational basis standard of review for “bear,” effectively gutting the Second Amendment;

— A decision narrower than everyone expects would get a nine to zero affirmation of an individual right (a seven-to-two split got a lot of voice);

— The Solicitor General would recant his position (calling for reduced scrutiny and a remand of the case), artfully saying that was a mistake or oversight, an extremely unlikely but appealing (to some) possibility that would get Clements out of supposed hot water and be talked about, well, forever;

— No one expects anything but an individual right finding, but the level of scrutiny for any law anywhere was up for grabs;

— Obviously, no one has a clue, but you get the idea of what was going on in the cold, windy, sleep deprived, hard scrabble concrete world of Hellertown in front of the Court.

As for me, I’m sun burned, exhausted, undernourished, but at least in a hotel lobby, getting ready for what sleep I can and an early start to what will be an amazing day tomorrow. I’ll relieve Bob so he can use the Court restroom to shuck his thermals, freshen up, stash his goods in the Court lockers, grab some chow in the Court cafeteria (great food, low low subsidized prices), and join the rabble in the cheap seats upstairs.

Written without adequate review or a spell checker, I reserve the right to change any of this… will attempt a swift review of the orals as soon after as I can muster.

Bloomfield Press, Phoenix
All posts will be on the website… soon.


One thought on “Alan Korwin is in line

  1. Alan isn’t looking very hard if he can’t find the gunnies in line. They are there. I took dinner to one last night.

Comments are closed.