The View From North Central Idaho
Ramblings of a red-necked, knuckle-dragging, Neanderthal

# Wednesday, January 18, 2006
« The price of ignorance | Main | Seattle wants a gun control advocate »
Another good question

Bruce at mAss Backwards left a comment for my post Just One Question:

I've been contemplating the "just one question" approach for a while now. There's a series of town meeting-style forums coming up in Boston with our Mayor Tom "Never Met a Gun Control Scheme I Didn't Like" Menino.

I'm going to put my name in for one of the limited slots available. Shoudl I get the chance to address the Mayor, I'd ask:

"Mr. Mayor, as you know, the City of Boston over the last year has seen a marked increase in the rate of homicides and armed robberies. My question for you is a simple YES or NO question. Do the hard-working, law-abiding citizens of Boston have the right to defend themselves from violent criminals?"

A "yes" answer woudl be an outright lie.

A "no" answer, though truthful, would be cause for his immediate removal from office (not that that's very likely, though).

That seems to be a very good question to ask as well.  The only disadvantage I can see is that they can say, "Yes.", "Yes, but not with a gun.", or "Yes, but guns only make the situation worse."  And you are left with having to justify the use of a firearm for task of self-defense.  My question forces them defend their desire to impose restrictions on firearms.  In nearly all situations it's better to make your opponent defend rather than for you to defend against them.

As I write this I see Bruce has posted on this "Just One Question" topic with the request "So...what would your "one question" be?" in the context of being able to ask some politician a question in a public forum.

Freedom | Gun Rights
Joe Huffman  Wednesday, January 18, 2006 8:41:47 AM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)  #    Disclaimer  |  Comments [3]  |  Trackback Related posts:
Quote of the day--Dom De Vitto
Herding cats?
Burning the midnight oil
At least it is an arrest
Growing the Party by Making it Smaller
Quote of the day--William P. Hoar

Wednesday, January 18, 2006 9:05:46 AM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
The exercise is pointless. You'll NEVER pin a politician down to a binary answer. He'll say, "That's a very good question. As you know, I firmly support the efforts of our fine police force and am working with community leaders, blah blah blah blah....."
Mike L
Wednesday, January 18, 2006 9:29:04 AM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
I've mentioned it before:

"So, the drug war costs billions and billions and billions of dollars. Many innocent, peaceable citizens have been needlessly killed by a police force that has been essentially militarized. People are not secure in their homes because of no knock warrants and search warrants issued based on the frequently false testimony of criminals. Property is taken and lives are destroyed over a few minuscule amounts of drugs. Is it worth that price to confiscate an infinitesimally small fraction of a percent of the drug supply in this country?"

http://www.saysuncle.com/archives/2004/10/07/well_i_have_to_blog_it/
SayUncle
Wednesday, January 18, 2006 11:28:53 AM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
One of my alternate potential questions centers around Menino's recent "Blame New hampshire" tactic, where he blames Boston's rising homicide rate on the lax gun laws of our neighbor states (NH, VT, ME).

Mr. Mayor,

When Boston had "only" 31 homicides back in 1999, that statistic was held up as incontrovertible evidence that the "most effective gun laws in the nation" were working, despite the accompanying fact that neighboring states such as New Hampshire, Maine, and Vermont had pretty much the same, if not looser, restrictions on gun ownership in place that they do today.


But, now that the murder rate in Boston is back up to its highest level in ten years, why is it suddenly our neighboring states' fault for allegedly flooding our streets with guns, as you would sincerely like the people of Boston to believe?
Bruce
Comments are closed.
Ads




On this page....
Archives
<January 2009>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
28293031123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
1234567

January, 2009 (28)
December, 2008 (82)
November, 2008 (72)
October, 2008 (127)
September, 2008 (86)
August, 2008 (65)
July, 2008 (96)
June, 2008 (94)
May, 2008 (78)
April, 2008 (75)
March, 2008 (117)
February, 2008 (113)
January, 2008 (100)
December, 2007 (75)
November, 2007 (100)
October, 2007 (93)
September, 2007 (95)
August, 2007 (85)
July, 2007 (67)
June, 2007 (71)
May, 2007 (74)
April, 2007 (54)
March, 2007 (73)
February, 2007 (83)
January, 2007 (80)
December, 2006 (100)
November, 2006 (101)
October, 2006 (99)
September, 2006 (100)
August, 2006 (100)
July, 2006 (100)
June, 2006 (100)
May, 2006 (73)
April, 2006 (66)
March, 2006 (64)
February, 2006 (83)
January, 2006 (100)
December, 2005 (99)
November, 2005 (109)
October, 2005 (95)
September, 2005 (107)
August, 2005 (84)
July, 2005 (81)
June, 2005 (82)
May, 2005 (68)
April, 2005 (78)
March, 2005 (110)
February, 2005 (61)
January, 2005 (88)
December, 2004 (89)
November, 2004 (45)
October, 2004 (35)
September, 2004 (23)
August, 2004 (13)
July, 2004 (20)
June, 2004 (11)
May, 2004 (9)
April, 2004 (17)
March, 2004 (14)
February, 2004 (22)

Feed your aggregator (RSS 2.0)
Search
Navigation
Home
Boomershoot
dasBlog
Categories
[RSS] A Security Theater
[RSS] Blog stuff
[RSS] Bloggers
[RSS] Boomershoot
[RSS] Crap for brains
[RSS] Current News
[RSS] Freedom
[RSS] Geocaching
[RSS] Gun Fun
[RSS] Gun Rights
[RSS] Home Life
[RSS] Places Without Guns
[RSS] PNNL
[RSS] Politics
[RSS] Quote of the Day
[RSS] Sex
[RSS] Technology
[RSS] When Prophecy Fails
[RSS] Work
Bloggers I Have Met
Alan Korwin
American Mercenary
Anthony Pacheco
Armed Citizen
Barron Barnett
Ben
Ben and William
Bitter
Brian
Cam Edwards
Caleb
Caren
Clayton Cramer
Chris and Melody Byrne
Connie du Toit
Chuck Ziegenfuss
Curtis Stone
Dave Kopel
David Hardy
Denise and Bill
Derek
DirtCrashr
Don Gwinn
D.W. Drang
Gay Cynic
Geek With A .45
Jason
Jean C
Jeff Bishop
Jenny Block
Jerry The Geek
Jim Rawles
Jimmy B
John D
JR
Julie
Keewee
Kevin Baker
Kim du Toit
Kirk
Kris Barrett
Kris R
Laughing Dog
Linoge
Lisa
Lisa Anne Auerbach
MadRocketScientist
Matthew
Michael Bane
Mike Brown
Mike W.
Mr. Completely
Mrs. Ahab
Phil and David
Og
Ride Fast & Shoot Straight
Rivrdog
Rob Allen
Ry Jones
Say Uncle
Sebastian
Shyam H
Squeaky
Tamara
TD @ The Unforgiving Minute
Thirdpower
Traction Control
Xenia
Zeke
Blogroll
[Feed] Alphecca
[Feed] A Celebration of Contemplation
[Feed] Idaho Sport Shooters Alliance
[Feed] Jenny Block
[Feed] Outrageous Malfunction
[Feed] Periodic Journal of my wanderings
[Feed] Random Nuclear Strikes
[Feed] reasonablenut
[Feed] Say Uncle
[Feed] Schneier on Security
[Feed] The Adventures of Roberta X
[Feed] The FOIA blog
[Feed] The Smallest Minority
[Feed] Snowflakes in Hell
[Feed] VPC Blog
[Feed] View From The Porch
Gun Blogger get together at the NRA Convention.
Other bloggers with guns.
Unorganized Militia Propaganda Corp
Unorganized Militia Propaganda Corps
Thoughts on Freedom
An Individual Right
TSA (A Security Theater)
Why Boomershoot
Community Policy and Personal Liberty
Destroy Their Culture
Just One Question
State of mind for defending the RKBA
Mental problems of anti-gun people
Jews in the Attic Test
Where is Your "Line in the Sand?"
Universal ID Card Fatal Flaws
Stop Intrusive Airport Screenings
Gun Rights Activitist Resources
Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms
Google News "Gun Control"
Google News "Gun"
Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership
Keep and Bear Arms
NRA Institute for Legislative Action
Second Amendment Foundation
Webmaster of
Boomershoot
Boomershoot Adventures
Lewis Clark Wildlife
Lewiston Pistol Club
Idaho Sport Shooters Alliance
Modern Ballistics
PNNL Bigotry Information
When Prophecy Fails
Family Websites
Photo albums
Joe Huffman
Wife Barbara's Genealogy
Son James
Daughter Xenia
Tools

Geek Tools
IP Address Map Lookup
Personalized Weather
Switchboard
Technorati

Blog Information Profile for JoeH
Add to Technorati Favorites
About

Powered by: newtelligence dasBlog 2.1.8102.813

Disclaimer
The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in any way.

© Copyright 2009, Joe Huffman

Send mail to the author(s) E-mail

Privacy Policy
Blogging info


Awarded July 2007


Awarded October 2008

Admin Only
Sign In